www.makemkv.com

No need to apologize.

Sarvajanik wrote:Would save (those of us who use this feature) a heck of a lot of time!

As would using the search function before posting.

Finally implemented in 1.7.8!


THANK YOU, MIKE!


Take that, WD

JoeDoe wrote:On DVD's it works great but Blu-rays have choppy separated pictures in areas of the movie (multiple different BD's).

That's total BS.

osohardy wrote:PGS subs are a pain, especially on mac

PGS subs are part of the official BluRay standard. There's no reason not to support them, unless of course you are Apple. Tough luck.

robpdotcom wrote:but if you want the subs to be identified by a filter that can pick out forced subs (such as the MPC-BE subtitle renderer), then you need to use BDSup2Sub on the Avatar subs.

OR a decent player like VLC that properly reads the flag from the MKV, or am I missing something here?

Why waste time demuxing/remuxing subs when you can simply do it via header editor?

Yet. Maybe Mike can code this. Of course I have no idea how complicated it would be.

I've checked the dmg file and it has mkvmerge too which uses the command-line on Windows.

I have not seen any talk about having to mux and flag the track as forced in any forums. IIRC this BD had no subs flagged as forced so you had to do it manually. How is it then that, as usual, Blu-ray players always seem to know? Good question. I'm not familiar with BD authoring (anyone have some i...

You could do it with a batch for MKVToolnix.

Simply uncheck the first two subtitle and forced tracks and then click the makemkv button and voila you will now have the movie with the force subtitles. Not necessarily cause not all forced subs are flagged as forced, as explained here . Playback is also much less of a hassle if you simply use VLC.

Check out this thread for why it's so hard.

No need to fiddle with command-lines when you can use Handbrake & Co. Also, VobSubs on DVDs are usually < 10 MB so it wouldn't make much of a difference keeping them.

Subs are usually small and turned off so why not keep them?