www.makemkv.com

Nop

If there is no forced subtitle track in the same language as the currently playing audio track, then no subtitel should be displayed in my opinion. IYO but not according to the specs. A forced sub HAS to be played, that's why it's forced. The player would actually have to play two tracks simultaneo...

As the others have pointed out, asking MakeMKV to help you work around broken players isn't really the smart option. Like i said, i wouldnt call it broken just because something isnt implemented. If something is implemented in the wrong way then i would say its broken. But do you have a better idea...

They're really rather fundamental functions of the matroska specs and there's really no valid reason not to implement them. You're problem is being caused by your player and nothing else. pls stop talking about the same things again and again. Everybody here knows what the flags are for. But the fe...

The players are playing MKVs without following the rules, how is that not violating the specs? Its not implemented. Thats all. There are also other things for example my TV shows "Deutsch1, Deutsch2, Englisch3" instead of the names for the tracks if have set. Just because they havent ever...

You dont have to reencode so thats Not true. The Players arent violating the specifications, so that also not true

as far as i know there are no players out there that respects flags. For example you have 2 sub tracks same language and set the forced flag on track #2. WDTV selects this track automatically? How 'bout you go find your players forum and go bug them about it. Well i could but i read many threads and...

We have genuine arguments for why your request should be considered low priority, okay tell me, because i cant find them. I think you have an other problem. We have a right to question the worth of your feature request, yeah, just read the post. NO Hardwareplayer out there respects mkv flags, so ev...

Okay guys, so you are against any features? Some say "Makemkv shouldnt because it cant" or "there are other tools for that" or "mike should concentrate on other things" So perhaps its time for a feature freeze? Well its okay if you are against any features but thats not...

yeah you are right. It's just an idea.

I explained the problem, the solution und why I think this would be useful not just for me.

correct me if iam wrong but MakeMKV is a tool to create MKV Files as far as i know. There are only softwareplayers like xbmc,vlc, etc that care about flags. Hardwareplayers don't they just activate the first substream or no stream at all. So for everyone who uses a Hardwareplayer and does not only k...

Many Players out there don't give a fuck about MKV default/forced flags and just enable the first Subtitle Stream. So this is not a problem as long as there is a forced Sub track. But when the first track is a regular subtitle track you have to manually deselect this track. A workaround could be to ...

If you want MVC MKV i would buy a Mediaplayer that can play these files. There is no free MVC software decoder on the horizon. So nobody knows when software like XBMC is able to play these files, perhaps never..

I still don't understand why everyone in here doesn't just buy a mede8er player and be done with it. Mine plays AVC/MVC 3D mkv files ripped with MakeMKV with no issues on my Samsung 3D tv. I'd never mess with trying to get blu-ray software on a pc to play these 3D mkvs properly. Way too much to con...

You dont need extract subtitles first. You can directly import mkv files into Subtitle Edit.

You can use *.srt but then you will lose any formatations