The rip now produces a Users\Lindsey\MakeMKV_log.txt file on 3800Client, a Vista (64-bit) computer, after I woke up and changed the MakeMKV preferences to require it. The log file is the first attachment.
I am now on v 1.6.0. The rip produced only 1 output title file which was not the feature title. I played the single title file on MediaClient (Win 7 64-bit) using VLC 1.1.4. A snip of the directory \\MediaServer\MyMovies\HD-DVD MKVs\Top Gun\ is the second attachment.
Is there a reason you've posted your HD-DVD-specific results in the Blu-ray sub-forum, rather than in the "General MakeMKV Discussion" sub-forum "sticky" thread devoted to this specific topic?
Based on my speculations and more knowledgable confirmations by "mike admin" regarding your several posts with Debug logs about both Blu-ray discs and DVDs, it's apparent that you have a problematic and/or dying Blu-ray/DVD player...